Ok, in reply to this topic in our Google Groups Page here is my rating
Forums & Categories:
Your forums are well sorted and well named, and I also like the News part as the home page, very well done.
Skins & Templates:
In the site skin I would give you a 7 out of 10, in the forum skin an 8 out of 10, I like the way you found a skin that blends they Forum skin and the Site Skin, very well done.
Banner or Logo:
Now I like your banne, but the banner looks like the logo (150 x 150), your banner needs a little more content.
Well, in the site I would suggest more content in the Downloads section, and forum wise, you should add at the bottom a 'Members Lounge' so you get a little bit more traffic in the site, maybe a Multimedia part, TV, MTV, ect...
Well your site is well constructed, and its not just a forum it has much more content. Members have a very wide selection on what to do in your site apart from the forum. I would give your site a 9 out of 10. Very nice site
If you want your forum rated here please read this article and do as said.